[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Chronicle article: Not a Bad Gig [HAPP-L]



Just one thing I disagree with. The word tenure where I work is a bad word.
The administrators fear it like the plague. We don't have it and probably
never will. However, there are few if any four year tenured professors that
I would trade places with. Like men and women we're different but equal.
Each has an important  role to play. I like my role at my two year
institution. J. Steele
----- Original Message ----- From: "Dee Silverthorn" <silverthorn@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
To: <HAPP-L@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: Tuesday, November 11, 2003 1:54 PM
Subject: Fwd: Chronicle article: Not a Bad Gig [HAPP-L]


Via Mary Anne Rokitka...


>From: pgyrokit@xxxxxxxxxxx
>Subject: Chronicle article: Not a Bad Gig [HAPP-L]
>Date: Mon, 10 Nov 2003 11:33:58 -0500 (EST)
>
>
>This article from The Chronicle of Higher Education
>(http://chronicle.com) was forwarded to you from:
>
>   pgyrokit@xxxxxxxxxxx
>   Mary Anne
>
>_________________________________________________________________
>
>This article is available online at this address:
>
>http://chronicle.com/jobs/2003/11/2003111001c.htm
>
>               - The text of the article is below -
>_________________________________________________________________
>
>_______________________________________________________________
>   Monday, November 10, 2003
>
>   Not a Bad Gig
>   By ROB JENKINS
>
>   Teaching at a two-year college actually has a lot of
>   advantages over teaching at a four-year institution -- and
>   certainly over being unemployed.
>
>   In my first column about teaching careers at community
>   colleges, I focused mostly on the bad news: heavy teaching
>   loads, little time for research, underprepared students, lower
>   salaries, lack of prestige. If my frankness made some think
>   twice about applying for openings at two-year colleges, well,
>   good. I've sat across the table from too many candidates who
>   had no idea what a community college was all about, and who
>   probably wouldn't have been there if they had.
>
>   But bad news, of course, is hardly the whole story. First and
>   foremost among the advantages is job security. I know you can
>   have job security at a four-year institution, too -- provided
>   you get tenure, which can be more or less difficult depending
>   on the institution. It's also true that not all two-year
>   colleges offer tenure, or, as some call it, a "continuing
>   contract."
>
>   But most community colleges do offer some version of tenure --
>   and it's often relatively easy to get. Unlike their
>   counterparts at four-year institutions, who may be required to
>   publish numerous articles and perhaps even a book to be
>   considered for tenure, community-college faculty members have
>   no such mandate. The truth is, at most two-year colleges, you
>   don't have to publish anything to get tenure.
>
>   You will probably be expected to participate in some sort of
>   professional development, but that could mean something as
>   simple as attending technology-training sessions on the campus
>   and going to the occasional academic conference. While those
>   are useful and worthwhile activities, they're clearly not as
>   demanding as writing a book.
>
>   More importantly, you will certainly have to show evidence of
>   good teaching and also, in most cases, of service to the
>   institution, because those are the primary activities of
>   community-college faculty members. But if you're able to do
>   that -- if you can document that you've consistently been a
>   good teacher, that you've served on committees and performed
>   other important functions for the college, and that you've
>   undergone at least some professional development -- you can
>   probably get tenure at most two-year colleges in three to five
>   years, seven at the outside.
>
>   Another potential advantage of the "teaching track" is that
>   you don't have to have a terminal degree. Read the ads for
>   faculty positions at community colleges, and you'll see that
>   nearly all list the same minimum requirements: master's degree
>   with 18 graduate semester hours in your particular field.
>
>   Don't assume that the term "minimum requirement" implies that
>   those with a master's degree don't stand a chance. Two-year
>   colleges actually hire lots of people with "just a master's"
>   -- two-thirds or more of the faculty at many two-year
>   institutions hold only a master's. True, some of those faculty
>   members are A.B.D., and many others have hours beyond the
>   master's. Quite a few go on to earn additional graduate hours
>   -- in many cases, at the college's expense -- and some even
>   complete their terminal degrees. But they were hired with
>   "just a master's."
>
>   Does that mean Ph.D.'s need not apply? Certainly not. In fact,
>   in recent years, the trend at community colleges has been to
>   hire more Ph.D.'s, partly because the market is glutted with
>   them and partly, perhaps, because word has gotten out that a
>   community college can be a pretty nice place to work. My
>   college, this past year, hired 16 new tenure-track faculty
>   members, six of whom hold terminal degrees. Ten years ago,
>   only two or three of the new hires would have had them.
>
>   That said, I don't believe that a terminal degree will
>   necessarily give you an advantage in applying or interviewing.
>   The faculty search committees I've served on -- at least a
>   dozen in the past decade -- were looking for the best teachers
>   we could find. Sometimes they were people with Ph.D.'s,
>   sometimes not. Our hiring committees tend to be "degree
>   blind," especially in the final stages of the search process.
>
>   Another advantage has to do with quality-of-life issues. In
>   addition to less stress, since faculty members probably won't
>   perish if they don't publish, community-college teaching
>   offers other lifestyle benefits, some quite tangible.
>
>   It's true that, on average, faculty salaries at two-year
>   colleges tend to be lower than those at four-year institutions
>   -- in some cases, much lower. On the other hand, two-year
>   colleges are often located in areas where the cost of living
>   is significantly lower than the national (or at least the
>   state) average. Many community-college professors are able to
>   live quite comfortably, despite the lower salaries.
>
>   In addition, most state systems offer excellent insurance
>   coverage, including health, dental, vision, and life, along
>   with a generous retirement plan. Many also allow faculty
>   members to take graduate courses within the state system at no
>   cost, and some even provide tuition benefits for their spouses
>   and children.
>
>   Prestige? That -- what there is of it -- is part of the
>   package, too. Over the years, I've known many colleagues who
>   were highly regarded in their local communities as experts. A
>   friend of mine, a history professor, published a popular
>   history of the area where he lives. A political-science
>   professor I know is frequently quoted in the local news media.
>   Others sponsor book clubs, give lectures to community art and
>   literary groups, or write columns for the newspaper.
>
>   Ultimately, though, the best thing about teaching at a
>   two-year school is just that: teaching. That's our primary
>   mission, and we know it. We embrace it. Our students know it,
>   too, and they expect us to be good at it.
>
>   By and large, we are very good at it -- especially given the
>   fact that so many of our students are less than ready for
>   college when they arrive. If there's anything more rewarding
>   in this profession than introducing a bright yet poorly
>   prepared (and perhaps unmotivated) student to the joy of
>   learning, perhaps for the first time, I haven't encountered
>   it. All teachers get to experience that occasionally.
>   Community-college teachers do it every day.
>
>   So, yes, my colleagues at four-year institutions are
>   publishing a lot more than I am. Some of them are even
>   becoming famous, or at least well known in their fields. Their
>   paychecks certainly have bigger numbers before the decimal
>   point.
>
>   But I seriously doubt that their careers -- or their lives,
>   for that matter -- are any more fulfilling than mine.
>
>
>
>
>
>   Rob Jenkins is an associate professor of English and chairman
>   of the humanities department at the Lawrenceville campus of
>   Georgia Perimeter College.
>
>
>_________________________________________________________________
>
>You may visit The Chronicle as follows:
>
>    http://chronicle.com
>
>_________________________________________________________________
>Copyright  by The Chronicle of Higher Education

______________________________________
Dee U. Silverthorn, Ph.D.

silverthorn@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

(512) 471-6560 office/voicemail
(512) 327-2441 fax

SNAIL MAIL:
Integrative Biology, Patterson Labs
1 University Station C0930
Austin TX 78712

EXPRESS MAIL:
School of Biological Sciences, University of Texas
Experimental Science Bldg. Room 1, 24th and Speedway
Austin TX 78712




===========   HAPS WEBSITE AT  http://www.hapsweb.org  ======
**** To UNSUBSCRIBE****
send e-mail to HAPP-L-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
   In the BODY of the message at the beginning of the
   first line put ONLY the single word  UNSUBSCRIBE
----------------------------------------------------
The mail being expressed is the responsiblity of the
original author.HAPS and Imperial Valley College, trustees,
administration, faculty, etc.disclaim any responsibilities.



__________ NOD32 1.554 (20031111) Information __________

This message was checked by NOD32 Antivirus System.
http://www.nod32.com





===========   HAPS WEBSITE AT  http://www.hapsweb.org  ======
**** To UNSUBSCRIBE**** send e-mail to HAPP-L-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
  In the BODY of the message at the beginning of the
  first line put ONLY the single word  UNSUBSCRIBE
----------------------------------------------------
The mail being expressed is the responsiblity of the original author.HAPS and Imperial Valley College, trustees, administration, faculty, etc.disclaim any responsibilities.