Lecture 62 (Focus): Indian Cultures in
History, 1783-1860
Introduction
The policies, legal precedents, legislation, and administrative
structures which were developed to guide Indian affairs in the early national
period affected each of the tribes chosen to illustrate the focus
lectures. All four tribes signed
treaties with the new republic in this period.
The Seneca signed not only an early "conquest" treaty, but also
a series of later treaties in which the government offered compensation for
land cessions. The Cherokee, on the
pretext of an unrepresentative treaty repudiated by the overwhelming majority
of the tribe, were forcibly removed to
The course of Indian history in this period, however, was more profoundly
affected by those who disregarded the government's policies than by those who
tried to enforce them. Treaties, Supreme
Court rulings, and ambitious federal policies did not stop squatters in the
East or trespassers in the supposedly isolated regions of "Indian
Country" to the west. Disease,
violence, and displacement recognized none of the arbitrary boundaries of
policy or jurisdiction. At the beginning
of the Civil War, most of the eastern tribes had been largely dispossessed and,
in varying degrees, acculturated. Most
shared the problems of factionalism, depleted resources, and disorientation,
and the plagues of alcohol and disease introduced by non-Indians.
Further west) the pace of change had been slower. Although guns, horses, and metal had become
an indispensable part of many cultures, such as the Navajo and
Lecture
62 (Focus): Indian Cultures in History, 1783-1860
I. The Northeast: Seneca Iroquoian Culture Change, 1783-1860
A. Technology
1. Goods
a. By the
1790s all clothing, except moccasins, was made of cloth (Wallace, pp. 191-92).
b. By 1800 the
European "agricultural revolution" sponsored by the Quakers was well
underway.
c. European
tools, from plows to spinning wheels, had become an integral part of Seneca
culture by the 1820s (Wallace, p. 310-13).
2. Settlement
Patterns (Wallace, pp. 311-12)
a. Towns of
log dwellings had replaced the traditional villages of long-houses by 1800.
b. By 1806,
under Quaker influence, the former town inhabitants had spread out on
nuclear-family farm-plots. They built
individual log houses, many of which were shingled, painted, and equipped with
panel doors and glass windows.
B. Economy
1. After the
war the Seneca became dependent on annuities and handouts from agents and
missionaries. In 1801, however, they
asked the government to deposit their annuities in a national fund at the Bank
of the
2. Initially
a failure among the Iroquois, the Congressional "civilization
program" became successful when it channeled its funds through the
Quakers, who committed themselves to establishing a model farm on the Allegany
Seneca Reservation in 1798 (Wallace, pp. 219-25).
a. This began
the Seneca's shift to family farming with both men and women working the
family plot.
b. By 1810
most Seneca were engaged in stock-raising (cattle, horses, and swine) and
farming (new crops included oats, buckwheat, potatoes, turnips and flax)
(Wallace, pp. 312-14).
C. Sociopolitical Organization
1. Social Structure
a. The major change in social structure was
the decline of matriliny and the rise of nuclear,
patrilineal
families, which resulted from the acceptance of the "family farming"
model
and the male assumption of the
traditionally female agricultural role.
b. This transformation was sanctioned not only
by the elite men (such as Cornplanter and
"important women," who
constituted the core of the matrilineal system.
There was,
however, some opposition
(Wallace, pp. 311-12).
2. Political Structure
a. The war for the
b. Cornplanter
became the effective chief of the Allegany Seneca as a result of his role in
negotiations, his character, and
the treaty annuities system. With the
rise of his brother,
political power emerged.
(1) In a successful bid for absolute political
power,
remove the League’s council fire
from Buffalo Creek to Cornplanter’s town,
despite objections from Brant's
Canadian Mohawks and others.
(2) Later in 1803 the prophet left his
brother's town after a quarrel and founded Cold
Spring. This caused dissension in the Allegeny band and lost
many valuable friends (Wallace,
pp. 285-95).
c. The ascendancy of the
the new center of gravity for
the Iroquois in the late 1840s.
d. In an attempt to regain control of their
affairs after unfair treaties had deprived them of
much of their land, the Seneca
called a convention in 1848. Seeking to
create a more
representative government, they
promulgated a constitution (Abrams, pp. 62-64;
Cohen, p. 421).
(1) The constitution modified the tribal form
of government without abolishing it.
The chiefs were replaced by an elective
council and courts were established.
(2) The
Allegany and Cattaraugus reservations
in 1849.
e. The
421).
(1) Because the Seneca attempted to forfeit the
Tonawanda Reservation as part of the
Compromise Treaty of 1842, the
(2) In 1856 the
their land from the Ogden Land Company. They paid $20 an acre for land that
had been sold at 20 cents an
acre.
(3) The
Tonawanda Seneca became a separate political entity in 1857. They did not
adopt the new form of
government because they were satisfied with the chiefs
who had resisted the sale of
their lands.
D. Population and Territory
1. Population:
In 1848 the population was estimated at 3,792.
2. Territory:
During this period, the Seneca lost most of their native lands (see E.,
below).
E. War, Trade, and Diplomacy
1.
In the years following the Peace of Paris, the federal government and
the states of
York
Abrams, p. 43).
a.
The federal government eventually relinquished its claim to sovereignty
over Indian
lands east of the state
boundary of
b. In 1786, at the Hartford Convention, the
state of
purchase" to the state
of
c. In subsequent years that right was sold to
a series of land companies.
2. The Treaty of Fort Stanwix (1784) and other
treaties negotiated with the Iroquois after
the Revolution
were "conquest" treaties, which forcibly deprived the Indians of
their
land without
compensation.
a. As a result of these treaties, the Iroquois
lost all of their western lands in
b. They retained only small reserves within
state boundaries.
3. The Treaty of Fort Harmar (1789) was the
first
compensation for land-cessions.
a. Although the treaty represented a
repudiation of "conquest" treaties, it reaffirmed
most of the
provisions of the Treaty of Fort Stanwix.
b.
Most of the tribes involved were not adequately represented in the
negotiations, and
the treaty did
not correct the abuses of the earlier treaties.
As a result, it provoked
widespread
opposition among the Iroquois and other northwestern tribes.
4. The Treaty of Canandaigua of 1794 corrected
many of the problems that the Seneca had
objected to in
the earlier treaties.
a. It gave formal recognition to Seneca land
rights.
b. It established the reservation system in
5. By 1794, when the western tribes were
defeated in the Battle of Fallen Timbers, the
widespread Iroquoian
alliance had collapsed.
6. In the Treaty of Big Tree (1797) the Seneca
ceded the bulk of their lands east of
the Genessee. Liquor, bribes, high-pressure salesmanship, and
individual weakness
were used to
obtain this land-cession.
a. The Seneca retained only 311 square miles
of land in
were as small as
1 or 2 square miles.
b. Cornplanter, who
agreed to the cessions, was given a private land-grant.
c. The tribe was to receive
$100,000; each Seneca would receive an annual payment
of $4 from the interest on
this sum.
7. In the War of 1812, the Seneca officially
adopted a neutral stance.
8. After the war the Ogden Land Company, the
latest holder of the "right of first
purchase," negotiated
2 treaties with the Seneca (Abrams, pp.61-62; Cohen, p. 420).
a. The Treaty of 1838 provided
for the exchange of Seneca "removal" lands in
Wisconsin for new lands
in Kansas and the cession of 4 Seneca reservations
(almost 115,000 acres).
b. Because the negotiations had
relied on bribery, alcohol, and illegal signatures, the
Seneca refused to
vacate their land.
c. As a result, the Compromise
Treaty of 1843 was negotiated.
(1) In this treaty the Ogden
Land Company returned the Cattaraugus and
Allegany reservations
to the Seneca.
(2) The Ogden Land Company
retained the Buffalo Creek and Tonowanda
reservations, as well
as the "right of first purchase" to the remainder of
Seneca land.
F. Intellectual Culture
1. By the end of the eighteenth century, the
Seneca were economically impoverished,
politically divided, and
severely demoralized.
a. Convinced of their cultural
inferiority, they slavishly tried to satisfy the whites.
b. Depression and chronic alcoholism
were widespread.
c. Many Seneca believed that
the incidence of witchcraft had increased.
2. Two factions emerged in this period.
a. A strong
acculturation-oriented faction was divided into two groups,
the more
extreme led by Brant and
the more moderate led by Cornplanter.
b. A nativistic
faction led by Red Jacket, Cornplanter's old rival,
arose at Buffalo
Creek.
3. A vision received by
revitalization
movement first among the Seneca and later among the Iroquois generally.
The Handsome
Lake religion contained both an apocalyptic and a social gospel.
a. Apocalyptic Gospel (Wallace, pp. 249-54)
(1) Ethics:
The four evils stressed by
magic, abortion,
and drunkeness.
(2) Theology: The idea of divine judgment and heaven or
hell as reward or
punishment was
adopted. Though native tradition
included the concept of a
cosmic struggle
between Good and Evil Twins, the notion of heaven and hell
had not been a
general belief among the Seneca before the
religion.
(3) Ritual:
The new gospel reinforced the native ritual calendar and expanded the
traditional
confession of witchcraft to public confession of sin.
b. Social Gospel
(1) Strict temperance was required.
(2) Unity and peace among Iroquois and amity with whites were
encouraged.
(3) The land base was to be preserved.
(4) Handsome
rejecting white vices
and the profit motives
(5) The religion emphasized domestic morality.
(a) Sons should obey
fathers, and mothers should not interfere with
daughters
(b) The sanctity of marriage
was stressed.
(c) The patrilineal,
nuclear family was favored above the matrilineal,
extended
family.
4. At the beginning of 1814,
Christian evangelization divided the Seneca into Christian and
pagan factions,
categories that overlapped the progressive-traditional (see 2.a., above).
5. By the mid-1840s,
the
church. The
Gospel was recited at semi-annual feasts.
II. The
Plains:
A. Technology
(Jablow, pp. 1-50)
1. Goods
a. In the
first twenty years of this period, the horse was the major acquisition; in the
following twenty years, the gun became the primary addition.
b. With the
establishment of
c. By the
end of the period, the
2. Settlement
Patterns: By the mid-1820s, the
B. Economy (Jablow, pp. 1-51)
1. After
becoming fully mobile, the
a. The
b. They also
participated in the widespread trade network established by the fur trade. Horses acquired from the Kiowa and Comanche
were exchanged for guns, powder, and ammunition.
2. Sioux
dominance of
3.
4. By the
1830s the buffalo-robe trade in both north and south was supplemented with
trade in horses and mules at Bent's Fort.
5. Medicine
bundles began to be "sold" to acquire capital.
6. In the 1840s
horse herds became a sign of status and a form of capital (Jablow,
p. 76).
7. By the 1850s dependence on traders,
warfare, and the disruption of hunts by non-Indian
immigration led to periods of
starvation.
C. Sociopolitical
Organization
1. At the family level, the growth of the
buffalo-robe trade encouraged polygamy since more
wives could process more
buffalo hides (Jablow, pp. 20-22).
2. At the national level, there were two
important developments.
a. Around 1812 a group of
(1) This paved the way for others who followed
in the 1830s after the establishment of
Bent's Fort.
(2) Although in 1850 the
Northern and
groupings.
b. In 1835 the United States, through Colonel
Dodge, first established and confirmed
Cheyenne "chiefs" for
the purposes of negotiation.
D. Population and Territory
1. Population (Berthrong,
pp. 22, 101, 132, and no. 12)
a. The
1846-1847; and 4,500 in 1855
(an exaggerated estimate).
b. In 1849 a cholera epidemic struck the
c. In 1845 measles and whooping cough struck
the
2.
Territory
a. Sioux pressure drove
between 1790 and 1800; in
later years the
b. With the Arapaho, the
c.
and severely under the Treaty
of Fort Wise (1861).
E. War, Trade, and Diplomacy
1. Village Period, c. 1784-1810: Sioux to the west and Chippewa to the east
drove the
2. Plains Trade Period, 1810-1840 (Jablow, pp. 51-77)
a. The
the Kiowa and Comanche to
trade with the
(1) This alienated their traditional trade
partners, the
(2) The
already tense Sioux-Cheyenne
relations.
b. The search for horses and the presence of
Bent's Fort drew the
the
c. The Great Peace of 1840 between the allied
Kiowa and Comanche and the allied
Arapaho and
(1) The Kiowa and Comanche secured a steady
supply of guns and ammunition to
use against the Texans and
Mexicans.
(2) The
and other goods.
3. Emigrant Treaty Period, 1840-1861
a. Exploration through
in 1842-1844. General Kearny followed the
in 1845 to
"secure" the route.
b. In 1851 the
concessions and brought
"peace." Congress, however,
found it too generous and cut
the annuities.
c. Warfare with the Pawnee and Potawatomi began in this period.
(1) Pawnee attacks on emigrants brought unjust
retaliation on the
(2) Heavily armed Pawnee, pressed for land,
moved against the
directly.
(3) In 1853 the Pawnee and Potawatomi,
heavily armed with rifles, defeated a
western Plains alliance of
the
some Kiowa, Comanche, and
Kiowa-Apache.
(4) In
1854 the
attack the Pawnee was defeated
by a group of Sac, Fox, and Potawatomi
(Berthrong
pp. 127-28).
d. In 1857 Colonel Sumner was
sent on an expedition to punish the
Cheyenne
expedition and the Pikes Peak Gold
Rush of 1858, the
peace.
e. In 1861 starvation and
depression had become so severe that the peace chiefs of the
warriors, however, refused
to sign the treaty.
F. Intellectual Culture
1. With the incorporation of
some Suhtaio into the
Medicine or Buffalo Hat
cult came into the tribe.
2. At the same time,
non-Cheyenne elements, especially self-torture rites, were
incorporated into the
Cheyenne Sun Dance.
3.
Near-tragedy befell the
bundle.
a. As late as 1866, attempts
were made to secure the return of the arrows, but all in
vain.
b.
Substitutes were made.
c. Much of the
Sacred Arrows.
4. Ritual broke down before compulsions of
trade and war.
III. The
Southeast: Cherokee Culture Change,
1785-1860
A. Technology
1. Goods
a. By 1825 the
Cherokee owned many looms, spinning wheels, wagons, and plows. They also owned ten saw mills, thirty-one
gristmills, sixty-one blacksmith shops, and eight cotton gins (Woodward,
p.144).
b. Some of the
wealthier Cherokees held slaves.
2. Settlement
Patterns
a. The town
system continued (Woodward, Chapter XII).
b. During the
Tahlequah Period (1843-1859), individual and family property ownership became
an important part of the town system.
Individual building lots were marked off. Some of the wealthier Cherokee
had plantations (Woodward, Chapter XII).
c. Some frame
houses and brick mansions appeared in this period.
B. Economy
1. In the
1790s family farming, augmented by some stock raising and orchards, was the
prominent occupation (Woodward, pp. 117-20,144).
2. The
Cherokee trade debt to the
3. By 1830 slavery and
merchandising had entered the economy, creating definite class distinctions.
4. During the Tahlequah
period, merchandising played a prominent part in the new capital city's
economy. The gold rushers provided an
especially lucrative market for services and goods.
5. The
Cherokee Agricultural Society was formed to promote fruit and vegetable
husbandry instead of cotton raising.
6.
C. Sociopolitical Organization
1. During the years between 1817 and 1827, the
Cherokee tribal government was reorganized
(Woodward, chapter XII).
a. The new government was patterned after the
the principal chief as head
executive, an elective bicameral legislature, and a national
supreme court.
b. The Cherokee Nation was divided into eight
judicial districts, each with its own local
council, marshal, and judge.
c. A written constitution was promulgated on
d. John Ross was
elected as the first principal chief.
e. The capitol of the Cherokee Nation was
established at New Echota.
2. The policies of land cession and removal
divided the tribe into two factions.
a. A minority faction led by the Ridges and
Elias Boudinot supported removal and signed
the Treaty of New Echota (1835).
b. The
majority party led by Ross opposed land cession and removal.
c. Division persisted even after removal. It culminated in the execution of the Ridges
and Boudinot.
3. The
Eastern (led by Ross) and
Western (led by Ridge and Old Settler) Cherokees. Both
groups signed a new
constitution on
4. The
the unity and stability of
the Cherokee government (Woodward 233-35). The Treaty of
1846 ended
unconstitutional federal attempts to legalize the internal division within the
tribe (Woodward, pp.
235-37).
D. Population
and Territory
1. Population
a. The
Cherokee population was estimated at 18,000 in 1837 (Woodward, p. 218).
b. Removal
took 4,000 lives (Woodward, p. 218).
c. The
population of Cherokee Nation West was estimated at 21,000 in 1859 (Woodward,
p. 252).
2. Territory
a. Twenty-five land cessions were made
between 1791 and 1819 (Woodward, pp. 27-28).
b. After the
Georgia Compact of 1802, the "Old Settlers" (1,130 Chickamaugan Cherokees) were removed to western lands
(Woodward, p. 130). They were joined by
3,700 others whose land was extorted from them in 1817.
c. In the
Treaty of New Echota (1835), all Cherokee land east
of the
(1) Some 2,000
Cherokee left during 1837; from June to November 1838, the remainder
were sent to "
(2) Cherokee
Nation West comprised 7 million acres in "
(a) Its
borders were defined by the
(b) The
Cherokee were also guaranteed a "peripheral outlet west."
E. War, Trade,
and Diplomacy
1. The Treaty of
a. This
treaty defined the boundaries of the Cherokee Nation (with some Cherokee
land-loss).
b. The
government also promised to provide agricultural and technical assistance.
2. The Tellico Blockhouse
Treaty (1794) ended the efforts of the Cherokee war faction. Then the Cherokee were able to turn their
attention to domestic affairs.
3. During the Creek War
(1813-1814), approximately 700 Cherokees served the
4. In the
Georgia Compact of 1802, the federal government agreed to hasten the extinction
of Cherokee title to
5. Federal
removal legislation, unconstitutional laws passed the state of
6. The Treaty
of New Echota was used as the pretext for Cherokee
removal. Although the treaty had been
repudiated by more 15,000 Cherokee, the Senate ratified it in 1836 and the
Cherokee were compelled to leave their homeland in 1838.
7. In the
Treaty of 1846, the
8. In 1846 the
Ross Cherokees called a month-long inter-tribal council at Tahlequah for
representatives of 21 tribes living in or near “
F. Intellectual
Culture
1. During this
period the Cherokee developed their educational systems (Woodward, pp. 123,
143, 144, 252).
a. The first
mission school was established in 1801.
b. By 1826
there were eighteen schools in the Cherokee Nation.
c. By 1857
there were thirty schools, with fifteen-hundred pupils; all teachers except two
were
Cherokee.
d. Many of
the wealthier Cherokees attended eastern academies and universities.
2. George Gist, or Sequoyah, invented a syllabary for the Cherokee language in 1821 (Woodward,
pp. 132, 1423).
3. Two bilingual newspapers served the
Cherokee nation (Woodward, pp. 142-44, 246).
a. The Cherokee
Boudinot,
resigned editorship in 1832 after joining the pro-treaty faction.
b. The Cherokee Advocate was founded at
Tahlequah in 1844.
4. A print shop,
vital at New Echota, was also established at
Tahlequah (Woodward, pp. 240, 249)
a. It printed as many as 250,000 pages of
Cherokee material.
b. It also printed similar amounts of Creek
material and some Choctaw material.
IV. The
Southwest: Navajo Culture Change,
1783-1860
A. Technology
1. Goods
a. During this period guns and horses were used
in increasing numbers.
b. Clothing
was modified Mexican style.
c. Metal
agricultural implements were distributed during the early American period.
d. Blacksmithing
and silversmithing were taught.
2. Settlement
Patterns (Spicer, Cycles of Conquest, pp. 214-15; Hester, "Ethnohistoric Reconstruction," pp. 136-37).
a. In
addition to hogans of the stone and forked-stick
types, cribbed log hogans were used. The forked-stick hogan
decreased in popularity.
b. In 1788
extended matrilocal family units were observed.
Although a nuclear family was observed in 1804, this isolated instance is an
uncertain indication of change.
c. Communities
consisted of ten to forty families spread over a large area.
B. Economy
1. Herding (of horses and especially sheep)
became the dominant component of the economy
(Hester, Early Navajo
Migrations, p. 89).